Abstract:

In a world where machines replace unskilled work, an active labor market policy - represented by the combination of an optimal Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC) and income maintenance for the unemployed - provides incentives to increase participation in the labor market and depresses wages for unskilled employees. In this paper, this policy is tested against the alternative of allowing unskilled workers to receive a means-tested basic income (MTBI), as recently adopted by Spain. For a liberal social planner (i.e., includes consumption and leisure in individual utility), the MTBI dominates the active labor market policy. For a conservative social planner (i.e., evaluates social welfare based on individual utility from consumption), the active labor market policy dominates the MTBI. The potential dynamic effects of active labor policy on labor supply were considered in a simulation by using updated empirical estimates; it shows that this policy becomes preferable for both types of social planner.